Skip to content

ByWater Solutions security incident disrupts library software

Summary

ByWater Solutions logo

ByWater Solutions disabled Koha plugins after detecting suspicious activity involving compromised Communico API keys. The broader vendor issue affected library accounts and mobile apps in Ohio, with a likely related account-access incident in Fayetteville, Arkansas. Most plugins were restored, while the Communico integration and two library apps remained restricted in the latest notices.

Key facts

Timeline

  • Incident start:
    ? Earliest known or assessed start of malicious activity or incident activity.
  • First public signal:
    ? Earliest public indication of an outage, disruption, closure or other observable incident impact. The signal does not need to mention cybersecurity.
  • First public cyber evidence:
    ? Earliest credible public information connecting the incident or disruption to malicious cyber activity.
  • Official cyber disclosure:
    ? First official acknowledgment by the affected organization or an authoritative public body that the incident was cyber-related.
  • Last impact seen:
    ? Latest public indication that disruption, degraded operations, recovery work or unresolved impact was still ongoing.

Primary victim organization

Organization types

Critical infrastructure sector

Incident characteristics

Assessments

Attack mechanisms

Data impacts

  • Unauthorized data access

    An unauthorized party accessed or viewed data without evidence that the data was copied, removed, altered, or publicly disclosed.

Operational impacts

  • Application unavailable

    A specific application or software platform became unavailable or unusable.

  • Downstream organization impact

    The incident caused operational effects at customers, affiliates, subsidiaries, partners, tenants, or other dependent organizations.

Extortion indicators

  • No known extortion indicator

    Available evidence indicates that no extortion demand, threat, communication, or related pressure tactic was identified.

Incident narrative

Analyst assessment

ByWater Solutions disabled Koha plugins across its partner environments after detecting suspicious activity involving compromised API keys for the Communico plugin. The provider’s Nov. 16 status notice and subsequent updates describe a security response affecting library integrations, with most plugin access restored and the Communico integration remaining disabled.

Cuyahoga County Public Library spokesperson Kate McCreary identified both vendors to Cleveland.com: Communico supplied its app and room-reservation platform, while ByWater supplied its integrated library system and online catalog.

The vendor incident disrupted library software connections and mobile apps. Cuyahoga County Public Library, Akron-Summit County Public Library and Westlake Porter Public Library each acknowledged unauthorized patron-account access through vendors and described a broader incident affecting libraries nationwide. Fayetteville Public Library reported a similar provider-related catalog-account incident in the same period and is assessed as a likely related customer occurrence.

Operational significance

Vendor response and recovery

ByWater reported potential weaknesses in Koha’s plugin architecture and deployed updates to its hosted servers. Its Nov. 17 updates said plugin access had returned except for Communico, which required further security work. This establishes an actual interruption to vendor integrations rather than a vulnerability advisory alone.

The disclosure identifies compromised keys associated with an integration. It does not establish that Communico’s entire corporate environment was compromised or identify how the keys were obtained. Koha is the software platform involved; the available evidence does not establish a compromise of the entire open-source project.

Documented customer impacts

  • Cuyahoga County Public Library, Ohio: The library took its mobile app offline after a Nov. 15 incident, discovered Nov. 16, and a vendor notification Nov. 17. The library said two vendors were involved. All branches remained open, and a library spokesperson said Nov. 18 that the app’s functions were available through web services. That workaround did not restore the app itself.

  • Akron-Summit County Public Library, Ohio: The library learned of the incident Nov. 17 and disclosed unauthorized account access through three vendors. It disabled its mobile app as a precaution and recommended that patrons reset their PINs or passwords. Its notice said library systems were secure.

  • Westlake Porter Public Library, Ohio: Its official notice describes the same Nov. 15 incident, Nov. 16 discovery and Nov. 17 notification sequence and involvement of two vendors. It changed passwords for accounts with potential access to private information and recommended patron credential resets. A service outage or app shutdown at Westlake has not been established.

  • Fayetteville Public Library, Arkansas: The library said it learned Nov. 16 of unauthorized access to account information in its catalog and planned to reset all staff and patron passwords or PINs. It said the issue had been fixed while its investigation continued. Its spokesperson identified Koha as the catalog system. In its Nov. 19 update, the library instructed patrons to reset their PINs or passwords and warned that the FPL app and library-card lookup could be unavailable during the work. Its FAQ gave no restoration estimate. No library closure was reported.

Customer relationship and scope

ByWater’s Aspen Discovery partner list names all four libraries. This verifies a common provider relationship, while the vendor disclosure supplies a concrete Koha/Communico security incident in the same period.

The Ohio libraries’ matching disclosures and description of nationwide effects support treating them as customers affected by the broader vendor issue. Fayetteville’s timing, catalog-account access and shared provider support a likely connection. Neither the provider notice nor the individual library notices publicly trace every customer’s exposure to the same API keys or exploit. Other names on the provider’s customer list are not treated as victims without incident-specific evidence.

Information accessed

The Ohio libraries reported apparent access to patron contact and account details, including names, addresses, email addresses, telephone numbers, dates of birth, usernames and library card numbers. Cuyahoga and Akron-Summit also listed home branches. They said borrowing histories and plaintext passwords were not accessed; Cuyahoga also excluded systemwide circulation information.

Fayetteville’s Nov. 19 notice listed names, addresses, phone numbers, email addresses and dates of birth among the information involved. It said payment information, Social Security numbers and borrowing history were not accessed. The customer disclosures establish unauthorized access, not a verified count of stolen records or a public data release.

Password-reset instructions differ by library. Cuyahoga said changes to its library PIN or password do not automatically change separate service logins, including Libby and Hoopla. Akron-Summit’s notice said its updated library PIN or password also applies to those services.

Confidence and uncertainty

The broader incident is assessed as active through Nov. 19. Reporting that day continued to describe the Cuyahoga and Akron-Summit apps as offline. The provider’s latest detailed notice retained the Communico exception. Other vendor services being operational does not establish recovery of that integration.

The attacker, initial access method, affected account count and complete customer roster remain unknown. Encryption, a ransom demand, extortion and data exfiltration have not been established. Recovery differs by customer; Fayetteville’s statement that its issue was fixed does not establish restoration of other libraries’ apps.

Analytic gaps

The initial access route, provenance of the compromised integration keys, complete affected-customer roster, affected-account count and final customer-by-customer restoration dates remain unresolved. The available disclosures do not establish encryption, exfiltration, an extortion demand or a responsible actor.

Organizations involved

Impacted locations

  • Fayetteville, Arkansas

    Medium Confidence

    Base city of a library with confirmed account exposure and a likely relationship to the broader vendor incident; no closure or citywide outage established.

  • Santa Barbara, California

    Medium Confidence

    ByWater publishes a Santa Barbara mailing/contact address, PO Box 1346. This is a city-level contact anchor for the affected provider, not evidence of a staffed headquarters, datacenter or local facility outage.

  • Stamford, Connecticut

    Communico identifies its U.S. office at 41-47 Franklin Street in Stamford. This is the involved vendor’s U.S. geographic anchor; it does not establish an on-site outage or compromise of the entire company.

  • Akron, Ohio

    Base city of an affected library; the documented customer effects concern accounts or digital services, not a citywide outage.

  • Bath Township, Ohio

    The Fairlawn-Bath Branch is in Bath Township. The location represents Akron-Summit’s library-network footprint during the account-security response and app restriction.

  • Bay Village, Ohio

    Bay Village is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Beachwood, Ohio

    Beachwood is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Bedford, Ohio

    Bedford is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Berea, Ohio

    Berea is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Brecksville, Ohio

    Brecksville is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Brook Park, Ohio

    Brook Park is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Brooklyn, Ohio

    Brooklyn is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Chagrin Falls, Ohio

    Chagrin Falls is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Fairview Park, Ohio

    Fairview Park is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Garfield Heights, Ohio

    Garfield Heights is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Gates Mills, Ohio

    Gates Mills is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Green, Ohio

    The Green Branch is in Green. The location represents Akron-Summit’s library-network footprint during the account-security response and app restriction.

  • Independence, Ohio

    Independence is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Lakemore, Ohio

    The Springfield-Lakemore Branch is in Lakemore. The location represents Akron-Summit’s library-network footprint during the account-security response and app restriction.

  • Maple Heights, Ohio

    Maple Heights is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Mayfield Village, Ohio

    Mayfield Village is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Middleburg Heights, Ohio

    Middleburg Heights is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Mogadore, Ohio

    The Mogadore Branch is in Mogadore. The location represents Akron-Summit’s library-network footprint during the account-security response and app restriction.

  • New Franklin, Ohio

    The Portage Lakes Branch is in New Franklin. The location represents Akron-Summit’s library-network footprint during the account-security response and app restriction.

  • North Olmsted, Ohio

    North Olmsted is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • North Royalton, Ohio

    North Royalton is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Northfield Center Township, Ohio

    The Nordonia Hills Branch is in Northfield Center Township. The location represents Akron-Summit’s library-network footprint during the account-security response and app restriction. The building’s existing renovation closure and temporary pickup services predate this cyber incident.

  • Norton, Ohio

    The Norton Branch is in Norton. The location represents Akron-Summit’s library-network footprint during the account-security response and app restriction.

  • Olmsted Falls, Ohio

    Olmsted Falls is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Parma Heights, Ohio

    Parma Heights is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Parma, Ohio

    Parma is the library district’s administrative headquarters. The documented disruption affected the public app.

  • Pepper Pike, Ohio

    Pepper Pike is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Richfield, Ohio

    The Richfield Branch is in Richfield. The location represents Akron-Summit’s library-network footprint during the account-security response and app restriction.

  • Richmond Heights, Ohio

    Richmond Heights is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Solon, Ohio

    Solon is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • South Euclid, Ohio

    South Euclid is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Strongsville, Ohio

    Strongsville is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Tallmadge, Ohio

    The Tallmadge Branch is in Tallmadge. The location represents Akron-Summit’s library-network footprint during the account-security response and app restriction. The building’s existing renovation closure and temporary pickup services predate this cyber incident.

  • Warrensville Heights, Ohio

    Warrensville Heights is a physical branch location of Cuyahoga County Public Library. This link represents the affected library network’s geographic footprint; branches remained open during the mobile-app restriction.

  • Westlake, Ohio

    Base city of an affected library; the documented customer effects concern accounts or digital services, not a citywide outage.

Sources

ByWater Solutions cyber incident disrupts library apps

Ohio libraries urged password resets after unauthorized account access. Most Koha integrations returned, but the Communico connection remained disabled.

Plugins temporarily disabled

ByWater reported suspicious activity involving compromised API keys for the Communico plugin, disabled Koha integrations across partner environments and deployed server updates. Subsequent updates said other plugins had returned while Communico remained disabled.

Change your Cuyahoga County library password now

Library spokesperson Kate McCreary identified Communico as the provider of CCPL’s app and room reservations and ByWater as its integrated library system and catalog provider. The library was awaiting vendor forensic reports and treating all cardholders as potentially affected; that precaution was not a confirmed affected-account count.

Cybersecurity Statement November 2026

The library disclosed unauthorized patron-account access through three vendors and a precautionary app shutdown. It described nationwide library and vendor effects and said borrowing history and plaintext passwords were not accessed.

Fayetteville Public Library suffers data breach; unsure what information was accessed

A library spokesperson said a provider alerted Fayetteville Nov. 16 to unauthorized account access in Koha. The library planned resets for all staff and patron accounts; borrowing history was not accessed and the scope remained under investigation.

An important update about your library account

Nov.19 update: Fayetteville instructed patrons to reset their credentials and said its app and library-card lookup could be unavailable during the work, with no restoration estimate. It listed names, addresses, phone numbers, emails and birth dates as involved; payment information, Social Security numbers and borrowing history were not accessed.

Library Apps

The library’s guide identifies mobile checkout in branches, access to holds and checkout lists, renewals and due-date and pickup reminders among the functions of CCPL Mobile.

Aspen Partners

ByWater lists Cuyahoga County, Akron-Summit County, Westlake Porter and Fayetteville public libraries as Aspen Discovery partners. The list establishes customer relationships, not exposure for every listed customer.

Cybersecurity Incident at WPPL

The library disclosed vendor-related account access occurring Nov. 15, discovered Nov. 16 and notified Nov. 17. It reported nationwide library/vendor effects, changed privileged account passwords and advised patron resets. It did not disclose a service outage.

See something that needs correction?

Signed-in members can report an error, update, or missing source.